★★★★★
You’d have had to have been quite literally living under a rock for the past few years to say you hadn’t heard of Cameron Winter, from his frontman success with Geese’s ‘Getting Killed’, which featured standout tracks such as ‘Taxes’ and the painstakingly gorgeous ‘Au Pays Du Cocaine’, to his debut solo album ‘Heavy Metal’, which changed the lives of every boy with a guitar; there’s no denying Winter has made a name for himself like no other. On December 11th 2025, Winter took New York City by storm with the sheer force of his voice, backed by piano, ambient lighting, and a sold-out, awe-struck crowd. Of course, Paul Thomas Anderson documented it, creating a concert film as splendid as ‘Stop Making Sense’ or ‘Nirvana: MTV Unplugged’.
To open with an unreleased song is risqué, yet ‘It All Fell In The River’ is endearing yet haunting in a way that only Winter can truly generate. The raw, poetic spillage of confessionary language recalls early Paul Simon or even Leonard Cohen, a piece of art that resonates with those who identify as an ‘old soul’, the type who reads the classics on the tube and underlines every unfamiliar word out of curiosity.
‘Rolling Stones’, the opening track on ‘Heavy Metal’, appears a few songs into the set as a highlight; Winter’s skilful, witty piano playing during the end of ‘Rolling Stones’ built up for a final verse that sends chills down the spine, an intricately articulated dwindling towards the next track, one that, suspectfully, the entire room was awaiting. It was followed by another undeniable peak moment of the night: the room-silencing ‘Love Takes Miles’. The simplicity of the lyricism is what makes it: “love will make you fit it all in the car” and “what I want is on my mind”; it’s relatable to anyone who’s ever felt love, in any sense of the word.
At this point, Winter truly earns his flowers, and yet, he’s not even halfway through. It’s almost impossible not to be led to tears during ‘$0’, a depiction of hopelessness only portrayed as despairing by the likes of Thom Yorke on ‘Ok Computer’, a brave reflection that blurs the lines between admirable and regrettable, not one to listen to daily, for the sake of everyone’s mental health, but beautiful, reinventing, and a sparing listen for good reason. Winter is fantastic at curating an unsuspecting build-up to a climactic bridge, and this may be the greatest yet; the song melds themes of self-worth and religious discovery, building something indescribable.
To close the performance, Winter performs ‘Vines’, a culmination of everything we hear throughout, a forward display of heartbreak, wrapped in a sonorous, sublime melody. This is only the beginning for Winter, and if this is what he offers the world at the start of his solo career, the rest is truly unimaginable.
Amy Porter
Image: ‘Live At Carnegie Hall’ Official Album Cover
